Can SEO Guarantee Rankings? (Answered)-SEO

Search engine optimization (SEO) is the process of improving the visibility and relevance of a website or a web page in the organic (unpaid) results of a search engine. SEO involves various techniques and strategies, such as keyword research, content creation, link building, technical optimization, user experience optimization, and more.

But can SEO guarantee rankings?

Are you able to guarantee that a website or web page will rank higher for its target keywords by using SEO?

In this article, we will explain if SEO can guarantee rankings, and if not, then why is that the case for website owners and SEO specialists.

Can SEO Guarantee Rankings?

SEO cannot guarantee rankings because ranking results are not static and there are multiple factors involved in how search engines rank websites in the search engine results pages (SERPs).

Why SEO Cannot Guarantee Rankings

SEO is a crucial component of digital marketing, as it can help websites attract more traffic, leads, conversions, and revenue from search engines. However, SEO is also a complex and dynamic field, as it depends on many factors that are constantly changing and evolving.

Ranking Algorithms Are Not Disclosed

Therefore, SEO cannot guarantee rankings for any website or keyword. Rankings are determined by the search engines themselves, based on their own criteria and algorithms that are not fully disclosed or predictable.

SEO Competition Fluctuates

Additionally, the competition and demand for certain keywords and topics fluctuate over time. This means that there may be more or less SEO competition for web pages across all subjects.

User Behavior and Preferences Change

Another thing to keep in mind about SEO and rankings is that user behavior and preferences that influence how they search and interact with websites are not static either. As a result, search engines like Google continually adjust the way web pages are displayed in the search results with rich snippets and user features such as images, carousels, review ratings, recipe information, business listing details, etc.

Google Combats SEO Ranking Schemes

Google is constantly taking action again SEO ranking schemes. For example, Google used to display FAQ data directly in the SERPs under web page listings that used proper structured data markup. However, SEOs took notice of this and began to abuse that feature by adding FAQ schema to web pages that don’t really need it as a way to enhance their listings in the SERPs to attract higher click-through rates.

In response, Google started removing FAQ data from websites in the search results, limiting the number of FAQ results for each listing, and penalizing sites that show signs of manipulating this type of structured data markup to get higher rankings.

SEO Is Not a One-Time Solution

Because of these factors, SEO is not a one-time or quick-fix solution to guarantee rankings. It requires ongoing research, analysis, testing, monitoring, and adjustment to keep up with the changes and challenges in the online environment.

Moreover, SEO is not a guarantee of success. It does not promise or ensure that a website will rank on the first page or the top position of the search results for any given keyword or query just because search engine optimization strategies have been applied.

In fact, no SEO agency or expert can legitimately guarantee rankings for any website. This is because rankings are not under their control or influence. They are determined by the search engines themselves, based on their own criteria and algorithms.

Therefore, anyone who claims to guarantee rankings for SEO is either lying, misleading, or using unethical or risky methods that can harm your website in the long run.

Reasons You Should Be Wary of Guaranteed SEO Rankings

Offering Guaranteed SEO Rankings Is Against Google’s Guidelines

Google is the most popular and dominant search engine in the world, with over 90% of the global market share. Google has clear and strict guidelines for SEO specialists and Partners Program members that prohibit them from making false or misleading claims about their services or results.

Google also warns users to be careful of SEOs that claim to guarantee rankings, allege a special relationship with Google, or advertise a priority submission to Google’s search engine or paid advertising network. Violating Google’s guidelines can result in penalties or de-indexing of your website or a permanent ban from its Partners Program.

It Is Unrealistic

Ranking on the first page or the top position of Google is not easy or simple for all SEO keywords. It depends on many factors that vary depending on the keyword, the industry, the location, the device, the time, and more.

For example, ranking for a generic keyword like “shoes” is much harder than ranking for a specific keyword like “red leather shoes for women”. Therefore, no SEO can guarantee rankings for any keyword without knowing the context and the competition.

Guaranteed Claims Often Use Black Hat SEO Methods

Some SEOs may claim to guarantee rankings by using outdated or black hat SEO methods that try to manipulate or trick the search engines into ranking their websites higher. These methods may include keyword stuffing, hidden text, cloaking, link farms, spamming, scraping, hacking, and more.

Although these SEO methods may work temporarily or superficially, they are not sustainable or ethical. They can backfire and damage your website’s reputation and credibility in the eyes of users and search engines. They can also expose your website to penalties or legal actions from Google or other authorities which is why you should avoid any SEO specialist or agency that participates in black hat SEO practices.

They Are Focused On the Wrong Metrics and Goals

Ranking at the top of Google, Yahoo, and Bing is not an end goal in itself. It is only a means to an end. The ultimate goal of SEO is to drive more relevant and qualified traffic to your website that can convert into leads, customers, sales, revenue, and profit for your business.

Ranking high in the search engines does not guarantee that you will achieve these goals if your website does not offer value to your target audience. Therefore, you need to focus on other metrics and factors that matter more for your business success, such as click-through rate (CTR), bounce rate (BR), dwell time (DT), conversion rate (CR), return on investment (ROI), customer satisfaction (CSAT), customer lifetime value (CLV), and more.

Even if an SEO strategy guarantees your website a top spot in the SERPs, those rankings are worthless if it doesn’t translate into financial growth for your business.

Therefore, instead of looking for SEO guarantees, you should look for SEO agencies or experts that can offer you the following:

• A realistic and customized SEO strategy that is based on your business goals, needs, and budget.
• A transparent and honest SEO process that follows the best practices and guidelines of Google and other search engines.
• A data-driven and evidence-based SEO approach that uses reliable tools and methods to measure and report on your website’s performance and progress.
• A long-term and sustainable SEO partnership that is committed to helping you grow your online presence and achieve your business objectives.

How Long Will It Take to Get Rankings Once I Start With SEO?

It depends on many factors, such as the age and authority of your website, the competition and demand for your keywords, the quality and relevance of your content, and the resources and strategy you invest in SEO.

However, according to various studies and experts, it typically takes between 3-6 months for SEO to show results for your website. Some websites may see results faster or slower depending on their niche, location, competition, and target SEO keywords.

Can SEO Guarantee Traffic?

SEO cannot guarantee traffic because traffic is influenced by many factors beyond SEO, such as user behavior, preferences, trends, seasonality, and more. SEO can help improve your website’s visibility and relevance in the organic search results, which can potentially drive more traffic to your website.

However, traffic is not a guarantee or a goal of SEO. The ultimate goal of SEO is to drive more qualified and relevant traffic that can convert into leads, customers, sales, revenue, and profit for your business.

See this related article for more details about how SEO impacts website traffic: Can SEO Increase Traffic to My Website?

Can Off-Page SEO Improve Rankings?

Off-page SEO can improve rankings because search engine algorithms take off-site factors like backlinks into consideration when ranking web pages in the search results. Links are like votes of confidence that signal to search engines that your website is trustworthy, valuable, and relevant for your keywords.

Summary for If SEO Can Guarantee Rankings

SEO is a powerful and effective way to improve your website’s visibility and relevance in the organic search results. However, SEO cannot guarantee rankings because ranking results are not static and there are multiple factors involved in how search engines rank websites in the SERPs. Therefore, you should prioritize SEO for your website, but not make it the be-all, end-all, for the success of your business.

The Editorial Staff at SEO Chatter is a team of search engine optimization and digital marketing experts led by Stephen Hockman with more than 15 years of experience in search engine marketing. We publish guides on the fundamentals of SEO for beginner marketers.